A Letter from Nantwich

February 2009 (2)                                                                      Cllr McGinnis replies | Update

Pie in the sky?

Walled garden? Metal fencing marks the boundary of an historic area.

NO-ONE said it was going to be easy. Eight years ago when a group of Nantwich people set out to restore a little bit of Nantwich's history to a neglected area just outside the town centre, they would have little realised just what they were letting themselves in for.

   Their mission was to save for posterity, and restore to a semblance of its former use, what was little more than an overgrown site. But this was a piece of land with a royal connection. This was the former garden of Townsend House - long demolished - to which King James the First paid a visit on August 27, 1617. He was a guest of the Wilbraham family, who lived in the house for 200 years and who had built the house in 1580 when Queen Elizabeth I was reigning. He had come to see the town's salt workings.

   Battling to save the land are members of Nantwich Walled Garden Society (NWGS) who have taken on a number of property developers over the years.

   But while they found the townspeople were behind them, Nantwich Town Council, whose job it is to represent the town and its interests, are apparently not behind the project and have not supported the views of the townsfolk. (Well, some of the members have, but in local democracy the majority decision prevails).

   Indeed, one member of the council has called the project to turn the former garden into a tourist attraction "pie in the sky". Cllr Bill McGinnis - who is also a leading contender in the battle to get the town's First Responder scheme restored to its former standard of service - said: "There is no other viable option for this site, which is in a terrible state, other than this application (to build six homes and two apartment blocks)."

   Quoted in The Nantwich Chronicle (February 18), he added: "It is like a jungle in there." Developing his "pie in the sky" theme, he said: "Not only would it cost £1million to buy the land, there are huge extra costs like maintenance. It would never happen."

   There are two things there. ". . . in a terrible state." "It is like a jungle in there." (See below). Doesn't Cllr McGinnis know that untended gardens grow wild and that they can soon be tamed into a thing of beauty?  

   Not unnaturally, the NWGS disagrees with the verdict that "it would never happen." They believe they could get the land for much less than £1million and can "restore the Elizabethan garden in four phases over four or five years for a basic recreation cost of £140,000 through sponsorship and by seeking a Heritage Lottery grant."

   The current developers, the Dowhill Group, has submitted new plans to Crewe and Nantwich Borough Council (which will disappear from the local government scene on March 31 when the new Cheshire East Council absorbs it into a new local authority). The latest plan included more car parking - in a one-acre area which would have seen the new homes all but wipe out the former garden. Despite a call by the Government for more homes, do we really need more houses in Nantwich? (When I went to get the pictures on this page, I noticed that more houses were being built. See below.) As far as I am aware, the houses at Stapeley Water Gardens - which include cheaper, more affordable houses - haven't been started yet. And I see that some houses in Imperial Court, Millstone Lane, are being offered for let (others are for sale) which may indicate that people are not rushing to buy there.  

   In the wall of the garden, which is listed as Grade 2 by English Heritage, are three recesses described as bee boles, where wicker bee hives would have been installed. Cllr McGinnis, in his enthusiasm for the revised plan, says the bee boles would be repaired - "which is a big improvement on previous plans," he said. But the bee boles would be only a small part of the whole plan.

   And NWGS Secretary, Dr Nicola Booth, told The Chronicle: "Extra parking spaces means more of the garden will be eaten up." She added: "We still hope to open this is a tourist site and it would be great for school children to visit."

   Dowhill's agent, Robert Holmes, is quoted as saying: "This will lead to a slight absorption of car parking spaces but we do want to keep as much of the precious garden as possible.

   "However, we cannot ignore Cheshire County Council's requirement for adequate spaces and Nantwich Town Council's desire to keep cars from spilling on to the Kingsley Village estate."

   There will be no parking space on the walled garden site - according to the NWGS Garden Plan (see this external website).  But many sites which attract visitors, not just in Nantwich, do not have on-site parking, relying instead on the town's, or city's, public car park. Visitors to the walled garden will park on various town centre car parks.       

   The Town Council should be backing this unique area, not more housing.

   Back in the late 1970s, when I was Chairman of the amdram society, Nantwich Players, members voted to support financially the conversion of a derelict building. If they had been as negative as Nantwich Town Council is currently being there would be no Nantwich Players' Theatre. I told the Players' members to have faith, take a leap into the future and back the conversion. They did, and it paid off. Nantwich Town Council should do the same.      

Another view of the damaged wall

 

The walled garden from Kingsley Village

l See this Letter from Nantwich for an earlier assault on the walled garden idea by a Nantwich Town Councillor.

l For the record, I am the webmaster of the NWGS website. But all the views expressed on that come from the officials. I don't have any say on what goes on the site.  

"NWGS can be proud that, though their efforts, a much better development application has resulted"

Cllr McGinnis sent me this statement:

THE NWGS members have their agenda and I am certain the majority of the townsfolk would say

"Hurrah" if some means of funding restoration, maintenance and security could be found. Unfortunately, despite attempts over a number of years, there is nothing in the pot.

    It is entirely understandable that members have high aspirations but at the Town Council we do need to consider practical issues.

   The Town Council has not opposed the aims of the NWGS. However, it has consistently called for a viable plan before any financial backing could be given. The document produced by the society had several glaring flaws which gave rise to questions which have gone unanswered.

   Leaving aside all the doubts surrounding the purchase and restoration, there remains the major problems of the ongoing costs - the gardeners, the maintenance of the structures and the security of the site. In addition, if the garden were to prove a tourist attraction, the planning authority would be most interested in parking provision.

   It is sad that restoration is so unlikely - barring a Lottery winner or other benefactor - but sometimes we have to take it on the chin. I said at the last council meeting that NWGS can be proud that, though their efforts, a much better development application has resulted.   

   The site is a mess and will get worse. One fear we have is that it will eventually attract the attention of undesirables and that will give rise to a host of problems.

   All in all, I believe that the council's view is sensible and pragmatic. In all the circumstances, the current application offers a solution that will preserve the walls and the bee boles. 

 

Picture of Cllr McGinnis taken from the Nantwich Town Council website (Nantwich Chronicle picture).

l Back to the Letters index              lBack to the website index page         

FOLLOW THESE LINKS TO OTHER PAGES:  HOME | ASK ANDREW | CHANGING SCENES | CONTENTS | AIRMAN'S  GRAVE | CHARITY SHOPS | CHURCHE'S MANSION | DABBER | FAMILY LINES | FUNNY PHOTOS | GREENSPACES SOUTH CHESHIRE  | (The former) LAMB HOTEL | LETTERS | LETTERS UPDATES | LOST HOUSES | NANTWICH CIVIC SOCIETY | NANTWICH IN BLOOM | NANTWICH IN PICTURES | NANTWICH TOWN FC | NANTWICH VIDEOS | NEW HOUSING IN NANTWICH | NEWS ITEMS | OLD NANTWICH PICTURES | PLACES TO SEE | QUIZ | RIVERSIDE | SPOTLIGHT ON . . . | STAPELEY MANOR | STREET NAMES | THE HACIENDA | THINGS YOU SAY | THIS AND THAT | WEBSITES |  WHAT'S  ON | WHERE I LIVE